For Obamacare to work, we must ignore what insurance is

Obamacare protest U.S. CapitolLiberals are just now grasping the economic case against Obamacare that Tea Party protestors and town hall attendees have made for four years—and they’re still getting it wrong.

Witness Cornell University economics professor Robert H. Frank’s Sunday column in The New York Times called ‘For Obamacare to Work, Everyone Must Be In.’  In it Frank notes that there are two incompatible propositions framing the Obamacare debate: that people should not be denied coverage based on preexisting medical conditions, and that government should not force individuals to buy health insurance.  Both conditions, Frank writes, cannot be adhered to simultaneously.

He describes how banning the denial of healthcare coverage due to preexisting conditions without having an individual mandate leads to an “adverse-selection problem,” whereby people with expensive illnesses are willing to pay the universally priced premiums but healthy people are not. As a result, healthy people tend to drop out of the market, thus driving the price of insurance up. This never-ending process continues until insurance becomes exorbitantly expensive, as demonstrated through case studies from California, Washington, New York and New Jersey.

Frank further argues that the only way around the “adverse-selection problem” is to force everyone to buy health insurance. Labeling the problem “a profound source of market failure” and challenges, he writes: “We must ask those who would repeal Obamacare how they propose to solve the adverse-selection problem.”

There is in fact a way around this dilemma, however, and it doesn’t involve forcing anyone to do anything. It also demonstrates the genius of the free market and not its failures.

That solution: To treat health insurance as – surprise – insurance; that is, to treat it as a voluntary plan that you can invest in if you want or take your chances and decline to purchase if you’re young and healthy. If you decline and get sick, then it’s up to you to pay for your expenses, including potentially relying on savings, family, loans or charity to pay for your healthcare.

Sure, in this system, there are lots of people forking over thousands of dollars a year to insurance companies and getting nothing in return because they are “unlucky” enough to remain healthy. But this is how the insurance companies stay in business – in order to be able to pay a “jackpot” to the few people who develop expensive illnesses their reserves need to be funded by the thousands of other people who don’t get sick.

Insurance with high deductibles is still generally available for people with preexisting conditions for some serious illnesses, and those who have trouble finding insurance can join high-risk pools set up in their states.  But sick people can’t pretend that getting their treatment paid for when they already know they’re going to get sick is insurance.

Frank’s argument is barely more sophisticated than Ezekiel Emanuel’s embarrassing plea to young people several months ago to buy health insurance to show their support for Obama.  But neither Frank nor any other economist is ever going to come to a satisfactory resolution to the adverse-selection problem if they refuse to grasp the fundamental concept of insurance.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Helen Mirren is absolutely 'anti-gun'
Well, you can add actress Helen Mirren’s name to the list of celebrities who love to shoot ‘em up on screen and rant about gun control off screen. Mirren gave a wide-ranging interview to Yahoo! Movies Monday where she spoke about everything from her love of Vin Diesel to her laundry style to her opinion […]
Tom Cotton objects to his SNL parody

Sen. Tom Cotton (R-Ark.) had a problem with SNL’s spoof of him—but only because the actor selected to portray him was too short.

Maher tells PC liberals 'shut the f up'

Bill Maher's politics are not always the greatest. But when it comes to knocking down the liberal PC brigade, he is on point like no other.

SNL parodies Starbucks' race campaign

What if another company--say, Pep Boys (or Girls! Or Whatever!)--took on their own campaign to talk about gender and sexual identity?

SNL's "The Rock" Obama goes beast-mode

Dwayne Johnson hosted SNL last night, so naturally he had to play a muscled-up Obama, who can finally do all the things he really wants—like throw John Boehner through a window and rip of Tom Cotton’s hand.

White House

Carly Fiorina says there’s a ‘higher than 90 percent chance’ she’s running for president

Carly Fiorina’s 2016 campaign is all but certain now—and she’s making no secret as to whom she’ll be targeting.

White House promises not to use legal loophole to keep NSA spying alive if Patriot Act expires
If the Patriot Act expires, it will stop the National Security Agency’s bulk spying too. The Obama administration promised this week that it will not take advantage of a legal loophole to keep the NSA spying alive unless Congress re-authorizes the Patriot Act, Reuters reported. Section 215 of the Patriot Act, which authorizes the NSA to collect data on […]
In honor of National Puppy Day, here are the top 10 cutest presidential puppies

Today is National Puppy Day! To celebrate, we give you the top ten cutest puppies to grace the White House Lawn.

Obama: ‘By hook or by crook’ I’ll push my agenda through
This is probably not the smartest phrasing to use. President Obama had an interview with Huffington Post over the weekend and while much of the interview was his oft-repeated lines about how Republicans are the reason nothing is getting done in Washington, he added a new phrase about his legacy that is bound to raise […]
Obama tells Prince Charles that Americans like the royal family better than their own politicians

President Obama has admitted what we all already knew: Americans far prefer the Duchess of Cambridge to Michelle.

Congress

Sen. Harry Reid will not seek re-election
WASHINGTON (AP) — Senate Democratic Leader Harry Reid, the wily Nevadan who dominated the Senate for a decade from the minority to the majority and back again, announced Friday he will retire after five terms. Reid, 75, who shepherded key Obama administration initiatives including the president’s health care law, lost his role as majority leader — […]
Schock: Lincoln faced challenges too
Embattled Rep. Aaron Schock (R- Ill.) gave his farewell speech on the House floor Thursday, promising that it was “not the end of a story, but rather the beginning of a new chapter.” While his own trials are more of the “Downton Abbey” decor and Katy Perry concert variety, Schock likened this tough time to that […]
Boehner, Pelosi read mean tweets
Taking a cue from Jimmy Kimmel’s famous “Mean Tweets” series, House Speaker John Boehner (R-Ohio), House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.), Sen Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) and House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) got in on the fun and read some mean tweets about themselves in a video for the 2015 Radio & Television Correspondents Association […]
GOP blocks Warren's student loan plan
THE HILL — Senate Republicans on Wednesday blocked an effort by Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) to attach an amendment aimed at lowering student loan rates to the budget. Senators voted 46-53 against Warren’s amendment to the Republican budget resolution. Warren’s amendment would have allowed people with college loan debt to refinance at interest rates from […]
Rand really liked those 'Stand with Rand' trolls

During Ted Cruz's big announcement at Liberty University yesterday--which students were required to attend--some Rand Paul supporters decided to troll Cruz with some "Stand with Rand" shirts: