For Obamacare to work, we must ignore what insurance is

Obamacare protest U.S. CapitolLiberals are just now grasping the economic case against Obamacare that Tea Party protestors and town hall attendees have made for four years—and they’re still getting it wrong.

Witness Cornell University economics professor Robert H. Frank’s Sunday column in The New York Times called ‘For Obamacare to Work, Everyone Must Be In.’  In it Frank notes that there are two incompatible propositions framing the Obamacare debate: that people should not be denied coverage based on preexisting medical conditions, and that government should not force individuals to buy health insurance.  Both conditions, Frank writes, cannot be adhered to simultaneously.

He describes how banning the denial of healthcare coverage due to preexisting conditions without having an individual mandate leads to an “adverse-selection problem,” whereby people with expensive illnesses are willing to pay the universally priced premiums but healthy people are not. As a result, healthy people tend to drop out of the market, thus driving the price of insurance up. This never-ending process continues until insurance becomes exorbitantly expensive, as demonstrated through case studies from California, Washington, New York and New Jersey.

Frank further argues that the only way around the “adverse-selection problem” is to force everyone to buy health insurance. Labeling the problem “a profound source of market failure” and challenges, he writes: “We must ask those who would repeal Obamacare how they propose to solve the adverse-selection problem.”

There is in fact a way around this dilemma, however, and it doesn’t involve forcing anyone to do anything. It also demonstrates the genius of the free market and not its failures.

That solution: To treat health insurance as – surprise – insurance; that is, to treat it as a voluntary plan that you can invest in if you want or take your chances and decline to purchase if you’re young and healthy. If you decline and get sick, then it’s up to you to pay for your expenses, including potentially relying on savings, family, loans or charity to pay for your healthcare.

Sure, in this system, there are lots of people forking over thousands of dollars a year to insurance companies and getting nothing in return because they are “unlucky” enough to remain healthy. But this is how the insurance companies stay in business – in order to be able to pay a “jackpot” to the few people who develop expensive illnesses their reserves need to be funded by the thousands of other people who don’t get sick.

Insurance with high deductibles is still generally available for people with preexisting conditions for some serious illnesses, and those who have trouble finding insurance can join high-risk pools set up in their states.  But sick people can’t pretend that getting their treatment paid for when they already know they’re going to get sick is insurance.

Frank’s argument is barely more sophisticated than Ezekiel Emanuel’s embarrassing plea to young people several months ago to buy health insurance to show their support for Obama.  But neither Frank nor any other economist is ever going to come to a satisfactory resolution to the adverse-selection problem if they refuse to grasp the fundamental concept of insurance.

Comments

Polititainment

Sony hack just got a lot scarier

The group allegedly behind the cyberattacks -- which identifies itself as "Guardians of Peace" -- suggested that it will organize terror attacks at movie theaters when the film "The Interview" premiers.

Obamas talk racism with People magazine

People magazine conducted an interview with Barack and Michelle Obama during which the first couple discussed their experience with racism in America.

Stewart on 'Don't Jerk and Drive'

Jon Stewart barely held it together for a segment on South Dakota’s unbelievably terrible “Don’t Jerk and Drive” campaign.

Stewart likens spending bill to Cosby

The $1 trillion “Cromnibus” spending bill passed by Congress last weekend includes a lot of hidden provisions snuck in by various lawmakers—like the measure that attempts to block D.C.’s voter-approved legalization of marijuana.

Colbert is all in for Jeb Bush 2016
Stephen Colbert’s comedy news show, “The Colbert Report,” comes to an end this week and the comedian was worried that meant he wouldn’t have a chance to weigh in on the next presidential election. “Luckily for me, 2016 came early this year,” Colbert announced. Jeb Bush announced that he would “actively explore” running for president […]

White House

District court declares Obama’s executive action on immigration unconstitutional
A federal court in Pennsylvania declared parts of President Obama’s executive actions on immigration unconstitutional Tuesday. Judge Arthur J. Schwab, sitting in the western district of Pennsylvania, said presidents do have the power to use discretion in deciding how to enforce laws, but found that Obama’s recent executive action went much further than that.  He said Obama was writing […]
Obama administration extends Pell grants to juvenile offenders
The Obama administration has set out new guidelines that allow for students sentenced to juvenile correctional facilities to be eligible for federal Pell grants. The U.S. Department of Education and Department of Justice sent out a joint release Monday that clarified an earlier law. Congress in 1994 prohibited inmates at federal and state prisons from receiving Pell Grants […]
White House denies report that it wants to delay release of CIA torture report

The White House is insisting it wants the Senate Intelligence Committee to release its report on CIA torture practices, despite a report that Secretary of State John Kerry is trying to scuttle it.

Kate visits NYC kids; Prince William joins Obama

NEW YORK (AP) — Prince William's wife, Kate, wrapped Christmas gifts, helped preschoolers decorate picture frames and left an impression of a down-to-earth royal as she toured a child development center Monday with New York City's first lady.

The surprising opponents and backers of Obama’s net neutrality plan

Ted Cruz vs. Justice Scalia, and Obama vs. Jesse Jackson and the NAACP: The fight in Washington over "net neutrality” and has drawn up some strange battle lines.

Congress

Retiring DemHenry Waxman's farewell ode to govt

You'd think that, 40 years in, a congressman might grow cynical about the prospects of government meddling. Not retiring Rep. Henry Waxman (D-Calif.)!

Senate Confirms Pro-Gun Control Surgeon General
NATIONAL JOURNAL — The Senate narrowly confirmed a new surgeon general whose nomination was delayed for months in a fight over his comments alleging that guns are a public health issue. The confirmation represents a victory for gun-control advocates, even as recent polling has shown Americans moving in the other direction toward gun-rights protections. The […]
Congress gave DOD $3 billion in extra funds

Christmas came early for the Pentagon (and Lockheed Martin.)

Rand Paul's bill to repeal Obama's exec order

Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.) has filed a bill to overturn President Obama’s executive action on immigration.

Congress sends Obama $1.1 T spending bill

Congress cleared a $1.1 trillion spending bill for President Barack Obama's signature late Saturday night after a day of Senate intrigue capped by a failed, largely symbolic Republican challenge to the administration's new immigration policy.