The 2014 '30 Under 30'

Congrats to this year's 30 -- check out the full list here!

State Representative says cyclists should be taxed for “emissions”

Ed Orcutt

Think biking to work is good for the environment? Think again, according to Washington state Rep. Ed Orcutt.

Orcutt wrote in a recent email that bicyclists should be taxed due to the greenhouse emissions they cause while riding.

The Republican who represents Kalama wrote in an email that he supports the inclusion of bicycles in the Washington House Transportation tax proposal, even though Orcutt said he’s “not much of a fan” of the proposal in general.

His “valid reasons” are that automobile drivers pay a tax to use the road, but not people who use the bicycle lanes on these roads.

Orcutt then wrote about the environmental impacts of riding a bike, and that’s where it all goes downhill.

“Also, you claim that it is environmentally friendly to ride a bike, he wrote. “But if I am not mistaken, a cyclists has an increased heart rate and respiration. That means that the act of riding a bike results in greater emissions of carbon dioxide from the rider. Since CO2 is deemed to be a greenhouse gas and a pollutant, bicyclists are actually polluting when they ride.”

That’s not altogether untrue, but certainly overblown. Bicyclists emit about one ounce of carbon dioxide per mile, while cars emit three-quarters of a pound per mile, which includes manufacturing, according to an analysis by the European Cyclists Federation.

The Representative issued a retraction via email on Wednesday.

“First of all, let me apologize for the carbon emissions line of an email which has caused so much concern within the bicycle community,” he said, according to Reuters. “It was over the top and I admit is not one which should enter into the conversation regarding bicycles. Although I have always recognized that bicycling emits less carbon than cars, I see I did a poor job of indicating that within my email.”

If the $10 billion Democrat-introduced transportation proposal passes, the bike sales tax would add $25 on top of bikes costing $500 or more, in addition to the sales tax. Projections show this fee would only bring in $1 million in revenue during the next 10 years.

What’s next — will the Washington state government begin taxing pedestrians who use the roads, too?

 

Comments

Comments

  1. Roger Mitchell says:

    I think they should be taxes and insured myself I was required to drive on average 100K miles a yr on average as my job in a larger city and I have witnessed many autos wreck to avoid a cyclist with their pants cuffed up and white shirt and tie heading into the office district in their bike lanes . I have came damn close to hitting a few myself as they would swerve from their bike lanes to pass a slower rider I witnessed a lady one day run up under a box truck pulling from the curve as she had to cut her steering wheel hard left to avoid a bike that was flying much faster then the car’s at 25 MPH down the hill on east Cary street , He did not stop he peddled faster I followed him 3 more block and clocked him at 57 mph I saw were he parked and chained his bike and walked in to worked I went back to the scene and told what I had seen as did several others already there.. Guy had no insurance on his bike and the ladies insurance had to pay the bill and her face was tore up ): NOT FAIR if you want to ride the public roads and street I say tax and insurance and some form of registration and a plate with a number to tell who you are just like a car or truck . And this could happen to anyone Judge found him guilty and he was sued for what it was worth ? But he was a young lawyer so I guess the lady got some compensation over the last 30 yrs ?

  2. Richard Shutts says:

    Sir, here we are trying to build up the Republican Party GOP and you say something stupid like this. Are you on the Washington Majaurana? If not all I can say is you can’t fix stupid. Richard

  3. Aaron Mounts says:

    If cycling were more than a fringe means of personal transport, I could agree with the requirements for registration and insurance. I wholly disagree with the tax under all circumstances. That said, law enforcement should be just as (if not more) aggressive against cyclists as they are against drivers. The stakes are far higher for cyclists as almost any impact with a vehicle will be fatal for them. Thus the enforcement of traffic laws and bicycling laws (helmets, reflective gear, lights, etc…) against them must be raised to match those stakes.

  4. UnapologeticallyAmerican says:

    If taxing bicyclists for the emissions they emit riding a bike (CO2), imagine how much we could generate by taxing the House & Senate for all the hot air they produce. We could probably ballance the budget.

Polititainment

Miller wants Obama to go on long vacay

President Barack Obama hopes to "be on a beach somewhere drinking out of a coconut" in 2017. Comedian Dennis Miller wants him there now.

Daily Show on ACA madness: blame Boehner

May Jon Stewart's viewership not be goldfish in remembering the full breadth of the Affordable Care Act saga. "A mediocre Scrabble hand" is but a flash point in a much larger and difficult game.

Stewart challenges McCain to 'wrong-off'
  Sen. John McCain and The Daily Show’s Jon Stewart have engaged themselves in a televised media war. McCain recently appeared on Media Buzz where he was asked if he believes Stewart is fair to Republicans. Stewart used this clip in his monologue Tuesday night and replied to the question with “does the Pope sh*t […]
Long-shot for House may be on reality TV

Nick Di Iorio may have to settle for the TV screen instead of the U.S. House floor.

Snoop Dog smoked pot in the White House

Snoop Dogg may just have officially inducted himself into President Obama's "Choom Gang." The rapper confessed -- or bragged, rather -- to Jimmy Kimmel on his Internet program "Double G News Network" that he smoked a joint in the White House bathroom back in 2013.

White House

Polls: Obama White House incompetent at managing, worse than Darth Vader

The job of the administrative branch is to, well, administer the laws. According to a new Fox News poll released on Wednesday, most Americans think that the Obama administration is failing dismally at the task.

Obama wants ‘idealism and optimism’ for millennials in face of Congressional ‘crisis,’ refuses to recognize he is part of the problem
Now that “hope and change” seems to be played out, President Barack Obama has come up with a new catchphrase for millennials – “idealism and optimism.” In a speech at a Democratic National Convention fundraiser in Seattle, Wash. Tuesday night, Obama asked young people not to give up their natural idealism and optimism because of […]
President Obama admits he does not watch the news

During a speech during a Democratic National Committee event in Seattle, Washington Tuesday night, President Obama confessed that he doesn't watch the news. Throughout the speech, Obama predictably complained about the incompetence of our "broken" Congress and urged his liberal audience to get enthusiastic about voting for Democrats in the midterm elections this fall.

Congress and the President actually take action, Obama says ‘it’s so much fun’
“Girls just want to have fun,” Cyndi Lauper belts in her famous song. Apparently President Barack Obama wants to join her. “Let’s do this more often. It’s so much fun,” Obama said at a bill signing on Tuesday. Obama gathered in White House with members of Congress to sign the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act. This […]
Josh Earnest criticizes negative story for quoting anonymous sources, forgets the White House is always quoted anonymously

When White House Press Secretary Josh Earnest took a potshot at anonymous sources during a Monday briefing, he probably should have picked a meeker reporter.

Congress

Paul Ryan unveils new anti-poverty agenda

In another example of the Republican Party expanding its policy tent, Rep. Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) unveiled a new poverty-fighting agenda Thursday at the American Enterprise Institute.

Cruz to Reid: Leave Ritz-Carlton, go to Border
After President Obama turned him down, Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX) invited Sen. Harry Reid (D-NV) to join him at the border.  In response to Reid’s recent claim that the border is secure, Cruz said on Fox News Sunday that Reid’s perspective is skewed because he “lives in the Ritz-Carlton in Washington D.C.” “I would invite […]
Graham: Immigration reform crucial for 2016
Immigration reform will be crucial to the 2016 presidential election, at least one Republican senator believes. Sen. Lindsey Graham appeared on NBC’s “Meet the Press’” with David Gregory Sunday morning to discuss foreign policy and the border crisis. “Senator, the crisis on the border, immigration reform. This is an international problem. But it’s also a big […]
Cruz: Obama loves to blame problems on Bush
Why won’t President Barack Obama and Congress work to end Obama’s push for amnesty at the border? Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) believes the reason stems back to the Bush era. Cruz’s argument is that Obama’s Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program is the reason for the surge of child immigrants from Central America seeking illegal entry into […]
Rand Paul wants to see minimum wage be 'temporary'
Sen. Ran Paul has a very different take on minimum wage from the Obamas, a point of detraction he made clear Saturday at the Reboot conference for libertarians and conservatives in the tech sector. Unlike President Barack Obama, who wants to see the minimum wage raised nationwide so people can live permanently on it, Paul argues […]