Deadline Extended

Know a young conservative who should be on Red Alert's 2015 '30 Under 30' List? Nominate them by May 29.

State Representative says cyclists should be taxed for “emissions”

Ed Orcutt

Think biking to work is good for the environment? Think again, according to Washington state Rep. Ed Orcutt.

Orcutt wrote in a recent email that bicyclists should be taxed due to the greenhouse emissions they cause while riding.

The Republican who represents Kalama wrote in an email that he supports the inclusion of bicycles in the Washington House Transportation tax proposal, even though Orcutt said he’s “not much of a fan” of the proposal in general.

His “valid reasons” are that automobile drivers pay a tax to use the road, but not people who use the bicycle lanes on these roads.

Orcutt then wrote about the environmental impacts of riding a bike, and that’s where it all goes downhill.

“Also, you claim that it is environmentally friendly to ride a bike, he wrote. “But if I am not mistaken, a cyclists has an increased heart rate and respiration. That means that the act of riding a bike results in greater emissions of carbon dioxide from the rider. Since CO2 is deemed to be a greenhouse gas and a pollutant, bicyclists are actually polluting when they ride.”

That’s not altogether untrue, but certainly overblown. Bicyclists emit about one ounce of carbon dioxide per mile, while cars emit three-quarters of a pound per mile, which includes manufacturing, according to an analysis by the European Cyclists Federation.

The Representative issued a retraction via email on Wednesday.

“First of all, let me apologize for the carbon emissions line of an email which has caused so much concern within the bicycle community,” he said, according to Reuters. “It was over the top and I admit is not one which should enter into the conversation regarding bicycles. Although I have always recognized that bicycling emits less carbon than cars, I see I did a poor job of indicating that within my email.”

If the $10 billion Democrat-introduced transportation proposal passes, the bike sales tax would add $25 on top of bikes costing $500 or more, in addition to the sales tax. Projections show this fee would only bring in $1 million in revenue during the next 10 years.

What’s next — will the Washington state government begin taxing pedestrians who use the roads, too?

Comments

Comments

  1. Roger Mitchell says:

    I think they should be taxes and insured myself I was required to drive on average 100K miles a yr on average as my job in a larger city and I have witnessed many autos wreck to avoid a cyclist with their pants cuffed up and white shirt and tie heading into the office district in their bike lanes . I have came damn close to hitting a few myself as they would swerve from their bike lanes to pass a slower rider I witnessed a lady one day run up under a box truck pulling from the curve as she had to cut her steering wheel hard left to avoid a bike that was flying much faster then the car’s at 25 MPH down the hill on east Cary street , He did not stop he peddled faster I followed him 3 more block and clocked him at 57 mph I saw were he parked and chained his bike and walked in to worked I went back to the scene and told what I had seen as did several others already there.. Guy had no insurance on his bike and the ladies insurance had to pay the bill and her face was tore up ): NOT FAIR if you want to ride the public roads and street I say tax and insurance and some form of registration and a plate with a number to tell who you are just like a car or truck . And this could happen to anyone Judge found him guilty and he was sued for what it was worth ? But he was a young lawyer so I guess the lady got some compensation over the last 30 yrs ?

  2. Richard Shutts says:

    Sir, here we are trying to build up the Republican Party GOP and you say something stupid like this. Are you on the Washington Majaurana? If not all I can say is you can’t fix stupid. Richard

  3. Aaron Mounts says:

    If cycling were more than a fringe means of personal transport, I could agree with the requirements for registration and insurance. I wholly disagree with the tax under all circumstances. That said, law enforcement should be just as (if not more) aggressive against cyclists as they are against drivers. The stakes are far higher for cyclists as almost any impact with a vehicle will be fatal for them. Thus the enforcement of traffic laws and bicycling laws (helmets, reflective gear, lights, etc…) against them must be raised to match those stakes.

  4. UnapologeticallyAmerican says:

    If taxing bicyclists for the emissions they emit riding a bike (CO2), imagine how much we could generate by taxing the House & Senate for all the hot air they produce. We could probably ballance the budget.

Polititainment

Anti-Stephanopoulos artwork invades NYC

Posters depicting ABC News anchor George Stephanopolous and a smiling Hillary Clinton with the words "PayPal" and "Donate" written on them have been popping up close to the studio where ABC shoots Good Morning America.

Rubio gets first celeb endorsement

The Florida senator and official GOP candidate for president has just received a big celebrity endorsement from Rick Harrison of the popular show "Pawn Stars," according to a report in the Las Vegas Sun.

Snoop Dogg endorses Hillary Clinton

Snoop Dogg became the latest rapper to endorse the Democratic presidential candidate during his appearance on Bravo's "Watch What Happens Live" over the weekend.

John Oliver shocked by House NSA reform

John Oliver was shocked to hear that the House recently passed NSA reform.

Introducing the 2016 SNL primary

The weekend comedy show has been skewering candidates for president left and right -- some more than others -- so much so that we thought it a good idea to track the program's focus on specific candidates.

Video

t u

2016

Huckabee: Americans most distrustful of government

Republican presidential candidate Mike Huckabee claimed on Fox News Sunday over the weekend that Americans are more distrustful of government than ever.

Ben Carson wins Oklahoma SRLC straw poll

Dr. Ben Carson emerged victorious in Saturday’s straw poll at the Southern Republican Leadership Conference in Oklahoma.

Rand Paul vs. Christie and Walker on NSA

The Senate's fight over reauthorizing the Patriot Act has become a battleground for likely GOP presidential candidates.

Are LinkedIn users ready for Hillary?

The presidential hopeful announced her arrival to the professional social networking site on Thursday with a post listing “Four Ways to Jump-Start Small Business.”

Clinton Foundation got $26M in undisclosed payments

The Clinton Foundation on Thursday made public that it received up to $26.4 million in previously undisclosed payments from corporations, universities, and even foreign sources, according to the Washington Post.

Policy

NSA claims to be shutting down bulk surveillance

With key Patriot Act provisions soon expiring, and no legislative extension in sight, the question now becomes: will the NSA actually shut down their metadata program?

George W. volunteered to officiate a gay wedding

This year, journalists have been asking practically every Republican candidate whether they would attend a gay wedding—and have received a wide variety of answers.

Lindsey Graham rolls eyes during Rand Paul speech

Lindsey Graham's eyeballs practically fell out of his sockets when Rand Paul rose to speak against the NSA Friday night.

Professor: Americans can't handle owning guns

In an op-ed for The Dallas Morning News, Prof. John Traphagan, who teaches religious studies and anthropology at the University of Texas at Austin, demands that Americans give up gun ownership after several tragic, high-profile shootings that have taken place recently.

Obama: Climate change is a security 'threat'

Obama spoke of global warming's looming threat during his commencement address to the U.S. Coast Guard Academy in New London, Connecticut, Wednesday.