Leaked Obama drone memos are civil libertarians’ worst nightmare

DroneLate Monday night, NBC news revealed a leaked Department of Justice (DOJ) memo describing the Obama administration’s legal case for killing Americans with targeted drone strikes. On Tuesday afternoon White House Press Secretary Jay Carney awkwardly attempted to calm skeptics of the program by further clarifying that the strikes “are legal, they are ethical and they are wise.”

In short, the memo concludes that the extrajudicial killing of American terrorist leaders is constitutional if 1) an informed, high-level official determines that the individual poses an imminent threat of attack (yep, just one guy); 2) capture of that individual is infeasible (it almost always is); and 3) the killing would be permitted under the traditional laws of war (meaning mostly that you can’t kill too many innocent civilians in addition to the target).

The DOJ’s explanation of these factors has civil libertarian groups like the ACLU enraged.  For example, using some circular logic, the memo explains that the government can determine that an individual poses an “imminent threat” by simply concluding that they had been previously involved in terrorist planning activity and that there is no evidence they have abandoned those activities.

Put another way, if the government makes a secret determination that you belong on a secret “kill list” of active terrorist leaders, you are automatically considered an imminent threat and subject to extrajudicial killing (which is usually also kept secret).

One controversial drone strike involving the killing of a 16-year-old boy from Denver illustrates the potential problems with the policy.  The outraged family of the teenager, who was killed while eating at an outdoor restaurant, claimed the boy was unjustly targeted by U.S. forces only because the boy’s father happened to be a well-known terrorist.  Former White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs didn’t help matters when he sloppily justified the killing by explaining to reporters that, “you should have a far more responsible father if they are truly concerned about the well-being of their children . . . I don’t think becoming an al-Qaeda jihadist terrorist is the best way to go about doing your business.”

Although it’s possible (and even probable) that the family’s outrage was just al-Qaeda propaganda, when American intelligence agencies can’t correctly determine whether Iraq has weapons of mass destruction prior to an invasion, why should Americans trust those same officials to draw reliable conclusions about a single individual’s terrorist activity?

Whether right or wrong, it’s clear now just how far President Obama has come from his naïve 2009 promise to do away with the “false choice between our safety and our ideals.”

Recall that waterboarding suspected terrorists to gain intelligence was “torture” and a violation of the Fifth Amendment, shutting down Guantanamo Bay was necessary to “restore the standards of due process and [our] core constitutional values,” and civilian trials for accused terrorists were required in the “interests of justice.” Now, the targeted killing of an American citizen based on the classified opinion of a single Government official is legal, wise and ethical.

As President Bush learned quickly after Sept. 11, the only easy choices in the War on Terror are made in campaign speeches.

Comments

Comments

  1. Janet says:

    Barrack Obama has violated the U.S constitution and has trampled over american rights he has murdered a boy and without due process . What are the good americans doing about it . I don’t have too much sympathy for the father being a terroist but have much concern about the president of the united states being one . I want my constitutional rights upheld and want my elected officials to get some guts and do something about an out of control dictator in the white house.

Polititainment

Celebs gin up youth votes for midterms
THE HILL – With young voters more apathetic about voting and government than ever, several organizations are trying to woo the “selfie generation” to the polls this fall. “About half of those who vote in presidential elections do not vote in midterms,” explained Andy Bernstein, executive director of HeadCount, a non-partisan organization that partners with musicians […]
Maher to Cheney: light yourself on fire

As Hunter S. Thompson despised Richard Nixon with every drug-influenced fiber of his being, so Bill Maher carries on the torch for media provocateurs.

Colbert announces plan to defeat ISIS
President Barack Obama might not have a strategy for defeating ISIS in Syria, but never fear,  comedian Stephen Colbert has him covered. Colbert announced a unique plan Thursday night that involves raising Ronald Reagan from the grave, a captive radio audience and Monty Python-esque horse sound effects. “Remember in 1938 the radio broadcast of ‘War […]
Brand: ISIS better than conservatives
Actor Russell Brand took to Youtube Wednesday to compare terrorist group ISIS to conservatives, eventually coming to the conclusion that conservatives in power were worse than ISIS. Brand was recording yet another video aimed at attacking Fox News when he made the statements about ISIS. He was responding to Fox host Greg Gutfeld’s comments about Brand’s […]
Biden congratulates 'Veep' on Emmy win
From one Vice President to another… Vice President Joe Biden took to Twitter Tuesday to congratulate actress Julia Louis-Dreyfus on her Emmy win. Louis-Dreyfus snagged her third consecutive Outstanding Actress in a Comedy series win Monday for her portrayal of a fictional vice president on HBO’s “Veep.” Last year, the VP picked up the phone […]

White House

Obama: The world seems really messy because of ‘social media’

President Barack Obama, speaking at yet another fundraiser with a script that's been recycled more than a Hollywood romantic comedy, had an unlikely culprit for the world's problems.

White House scrambles to control the fallout from Obama’s ‘We don’t have a strategy yet’ comment
It’s hard to imagine that there was any other reaction than full panic from White House staffers after President Obama uttered a fateful gaffe Thursday afternoon, “We don’t have a strategy yet.” The line quickly exploded on Twitter and on television — though not quite as much as the president’s tan suit — as it […]
GOP: ‘He’s not a king’
THE HILL – Whether lamenting the so-called vacationer-in-chief’s swing of a golf club or criticizing his handling of the healthcare rollout, Republicans are getting in the habit of comparing President Obama to a monarch. “It’s one thing after another. You know he says he has no choice but to act. He says he has a pen […]
Obama’s Democratic fundraising just might ruin Labor Day weekend for the rest of us

Barely having returned from a 15-day vacation on Martha's Vineyard, Massachusetts, Obama will spend is Labor Day weekend traveling to support his Democratic friends. The problem is, this means that Americans planning to take seaplanes to East Hampton, Montauk, Martha's Vineyard or Nantucket won't be able to travel themselves.

White House flirt Joe Biden turns on the charm for 108-year-old veteran Lucy Coffey

Joe Biden continues to brand himself the White House flirt. In a recently released video of Biden's July 25 meeting with Lucy Coffee, the vice president kisses the 108-year-old war veteran on the cheek and hand and tells her, "I'm the guy that loves you."

Congress

Cruz highlights issues for 2014, 2016 elections
Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) elicited huge cheers from the audience at the Americans For Prosperity’s “Defending the American Dream Summit” Saturday when he vowed Republicans would take back control of the U.S. Senate and “retire” Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid. “I’m convinced we’re going to win in 2014 and 2016 is going to be even better,” […]
IRS says Lerner's Blackberry 'destroyed'

A senior IRS lawyer has said in a sworn declaration that Lois Lerner's BlackBerry was intentionally destroyed after Congress had begun to investigate her involvement in IRS targeting of conservative groups.

Youth impact reason enough to pass jobs bills
The U.S. House Committee on Ways and Means is in the midst of releasing 40 reasons over the course of 40 days that the Senate should take up the 40 jobs bills the House has already passed. While most of their reasons have focused on general unemployment and economic growth statistics, they turned their attention […]
UNEARTHED: Archival footage of Harry Reid smiling

From appearances, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid derives little pleasure from his job, perhaps a deputy to the paragon of joylessness. But Red Alert Politics has dug into the archives to demonstrate that it wasn't always like this.

Rubio: Obama action would kill immigration reform
Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.) is urging President Barack Obama to forego taking executive action on immigration, warning that would kill any chance for comprehensive immigration reform. “If indeed you move forward on such a decision, I believe it will close the door to any chance of making progress on immigration reform for the foreseeable future,” […]