Leaked Obama drone memos are civil libertarians’ worst nightmare

DroneLate Monday night, NBC news revealed a leaked Department of Justice (DOJ) memo describing the Obama administration’s legal case for killing Americans with targeted drone strikes. On Tuesday afternoon White House Press Secretary Jay Carney awkwardly attempted to calm skeptics of the program by further clarifying that the strikes “are legal, they are ethical and they are wise.”

In short, the memo concludes that the extrajudicial killing of American terrorist leaders is constitutional if 1) an informed, high-level official determines that the individual poses an imminent threat of attack (yep, just one guy); 2) capture of that individual is infeasible (it almost always is); and 3) the killing would be permitted under the traditional laws of war (meaning mostly that you can’t kill too many innocent civilians in addition to the target).

The DOJ’s explanation of these factors has civil libertarian groups like the ACLU enraged.  For example, using some circular logic, the memo explains that the government can determine that an individual poses an “imminent threat” by simply concluding that they had been previously involved in terrorist planning activity and that there is no evidence they have abandoned those activities.

Put another way, if the government makes a secret determination that you belong on a secret “kill list” of active terrorist leaders, you are automatically considered an imminent threat and subject to extrajudicial killing (which is usually also kept secret).

One controversial drone strike involving the killing of a 16-year-old boy from Denver illustrates the potential problems with the policy.  The outraged family of the teenager, who was killed while eating at an outdoor restaurant, claimed the boy was unjustly targeted by U.S. forces only because the boy’s father happened to be a well-known terrorist.  Former White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs didn’t help matters when he sloppily justified the killing by explaining to reporters that, “you should have a far more responsible father if they are truly concerned about the well-being of their children . . . I don’t think becoming an al-Qaeda jihadist terrorist is the best way to go about doing your business.”

Although it’s possible (and even probable) that the family’s outrage was just al-Qaeda propaganda, when American intelligence agencies can’t correctly determine whether Iraq has weapons of mass destruction prior to an invasion, why should Americans trust those same officials to draw reliable conclusions about a single individual’s terrorist activity?

Whether right or wrong, it’s clear now just how far President Obama has come from his naïve 2009 promise to do away with the “false choice between our safety and our ideals.”

Recall that waterboarding suspected terrorists to gain intelligence was “torture” and a violation of the Fifth Amendment, shutting down Guantanamo Bay was necessary to “restore the standards of due process and [our] core constitutional values,” and civilian trials for accused terrorists were required in the “interests of justice.” Now, the targeted killing of an American citizen based on the classified opinion of a single Government official is legal, wise and ethical.

As President Bush learned quickly after Sept. 11, the only easy choices in the War on Terror are made in campaign speeches.

Comments

Comments

  1. Janet says:

    Barrack Obama has violated the U.S constitution and has trampled over american rights he has murdered a boy and without due process . What are the good americans doing about it . I don’t have too much sympathy for the father being a terroist but have much concern about the president of the united states being one . I want my constitutional rights upheld and want my elected officials to get some guts and do something about an out of control dictator in the white house.

The Daily Show rips into Florida gun law

The Daily Show sent one of their “correspondents” down to Florida to "investigate" Governor Rick Scott’s law banning doctors from asking their patients about gun ownership.

Kimmel on the DEA's 'stoner rabbit' fear

In one of the more ridiculous anti-pot arguments we've seen in a while, the DEA in Utah is super concerned that, if they legalize edibles for medical use, all the local bunnies will get stoned out of their minds and lose their natural instincts.

Jon Stewart mocks Netanyahu

Jon Stewart spent a good deal of time Tuesday evening bashing Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s controversial speech before Congress, saying sarcastically, “Even though Netanyahu was speaking only two weeks before the Israeli elections, he wasn’t there just to use our Congress as the most elaborate campaign commercial background ever.”

Stewart calls House GOP 'turds'

Jon Stewart was looking forward to the end of congressional gridlock now that Republicans control both houses.

John Oliver gloats over net neutrality

John Oliver, who once spurred his followers to crash the FCC’s website demanding net neutrality, is positively gleeful over the news that the agency has approved rules to regulate the internet like a public utility.

White House

Calling for cooperation, Obama engages in confrontation

WASHINGTON (AP) — Amid appeals for bipartisanship, President Barack Obama in just three days has provoked Republicans on issues as disparate as immigration, Wall Street and the Keystone XL pipeline — a combative mix of defense and offense that underscores Washington's political realignment.

It’s on: Obama follows through and vetoes Keystone pipeline

Defying the Republican-run Congress, President Barack Obama rejected a bill Tuesday to approve construction of the Keystone XL oil pipeline, wielding his veto power for only the third time in his presidency.

Biden: The middle class is ‘being killed,’ in worse shape than any time since the ’20s

Joe Biden—everyone’s favorite creeper and truth-bomb-dropper.

MSNBC Host: Obama’s terrorism summit is a ‘dog and pony show’
You know it’s bad when President Obama has even lost the support of MSNBC. MSNBC Host Andrea Mitchell basically called the White House’s Summit on “Countering Violent Extremism” a farce during her show Wednesday. “Here he has the summit, no heads of government coming, the participation has not been at a particularly high level. We’ll have […]
Obama assures ‘almost complete confidence’ there have been no NSA abuses

The president’s interview with Re/code over the weekend touched on privacy issues, with Obama insisting with “almost complete confidence” that there have been no abuses of the government’s vast surveillance program.

Congress

DeSantis, Lee push for higher education reform
Higher education is finally getting some attention from Republicans in Congress. Rep. Ron DeSantis (R- Fla.) introduced the Higher Education Reform and Opportunity (HERO) Act Wednesday, the House companion legislation to what was introduced in the Senate by Sen. Mike Lee (R- Utah). The HERO Act would allow states to create their own accreditation systems for […]
Can Congress pass NSA reform in the next 100 days?

After failing to pass NSA reform last year, Congress has less than 100 days left to try again, or allow the entire phone metadata program to sunset on June 1.

Trey Gowdy says he's going straight to Hillary

Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton's email controversy has opened up a new front in the House's investigation of the 2012 Benghazi attack, with Rep. Trey Gowdy saying Tuesday that his investigators would be going straight to Clinton and her team to obtain all relevant correspondence.

More Congressmen had student loan debt this year
The student loan debt crisis is not just a growing problem among the American public, it’s growing among members of Congress as well. A grand total of 47 members of Congress reported a cumulative total of between $1.8 million and $4.6 million in student loan debt in 2013, as calculated by OpenSecrets based on personal […]
Congress sends Homeland Security bill to Obama

Congress is sending President Barack Obama a bill to fund the Department of Homeland Security through the end of the budget year, without overturning the president's immigration policies.