Hipsters respond to Princeton professor’s harsh critique of the “ironic” Millennial Generation

Millennials are hiding from life behind their hipster glasses. Or at least Princeton University Professor Christy Wampole thinks so.

In an opinion piece that appeared in the New York Times last November headlined “How to live without Irony,” she wrote, “Irony is the ethos of our age” and “the hipster is our archetype of ironic living.”

The ‘i’ in ‘iGen’ apparently stands for ironic.

This is not a compliment to hipsters. Wampole argues that “irony is the most self-defensive mode, as it allows a person to dodge responsibility for his or her choices, aesthetic and otherwise.”

Little did she know that she messed with the wrong subculture.

Self-proclaimed hipster and HuffPost Live producer Jacob Soboroff took offense to Wampole’s attack and aired his grievances publicly on HuffPost Live Thursday.

“I thought this was unduly harsh on hipsters and threw the ironic label on hipsters,” he said. “It rubbed me the wrong way.”

Jonathan Fitzgerald, author of “Not Your Mother’s Morals,” said the piece was a “punch in the stomach” during the web show. “I was so pissed off,” he added.

But after the hipsters on HuffPo were done venting about how Wampole misunderstood them, they dove into the question of whether Millennials actually are ironic.

Radical Social Entrepreneurs editor Zachary Caceres, also a guest on the show, argued that Millennials are ironic because of how “absurd” today’s world is.

In response to Wampole’s article, Caceres wrote on his website, “Our leaders regularly lie to us (the truth hurts), and people who actually tell the truth are punished by those in power.”

He continues,“We can’t find jobs and we can find even fewer that are meaningful or offer upward mobility….we’re paying off our gargantuan student debts or more likely, not being able to pay them.”

HuffPost College Senior Editor Will McGuinness also cited the atrocious youth unemployment rate as a reason. “Millennials are more than ironic, they’re pessimistic,” he noted.

In an effort to be positive, Soboroff said that Millennials could also be described as “sincere,” arguing that more and more college graduates are joining service corps like Teach for America.

But McGuinness was quick to shoot down Soboroff’s ‘Pollyanna’ interpretation of the economic situation young people are facing.

“That’s just a funnel for people who don’t have the opportunity they thought they were going to get,” he fired back.

Soboroff then threw out the word “apathy” to describe the iGeneration because “they don’t really vote.”

“Less than half show up to the polls,” he added (which is technically true – 49.3 percent of Millenials voted in the last presidential election.)

So, to put it bluntly, even Millennials think the Millennial Generation is ironic, pessimistic, and apathetic.

Cheers, iGen!

 

Comments

Polititainment

HOC star wants Bill Clinton cameo

"House of Cards" star Michael Kelly in an interview with The Hill at the White House Correspondents' Association dinner late last month said that he would "love" to see Bill Clinton land a cameo role on the Netflix political drama.

Stewart plays 'Let’s Get Rid of Cruz'

Jon Stewart came up with a super clever game to narrow the GOP field—it’s called “Let’s Get Rid of Ted Cruz.”

Letterman hits Boehner, Clinton and Cruz
In David Letterman’s opening monologue Tuesday night, the comedian presented “John Boehner: News You Can Use,” featuring what would seem irrelevant when taken out of context. For instance, Boehner says in one clip, “We spend more money on antacids than we do on politics.” Letterman also cracked wise about Hillary Clinton’s Mother’s Day fundraiser where she will […]
Sofia Vergara: Obama charming, handsome

The actress told Howard Stern Monday that she had a brief and pleasant encounter with the president during a tour of the White House in 2013 with her "Modern Family" costars ahead of that year's White House Correspondents' dinner.

Stewart weighs in on Garland shooting

Jon Stewart had a message Monday night--and he repeated it a lot, because people were seemingly not getting it.

2016

Millennial calls Hillary out for hypocrisy

National Review's Katherine Timpf, a self-described "middle-class Millennial female," recently penned a hilarious letter to Hillary Clinton that perfectly captures her hypocrisy on a number of issues.

Clinton will go further than Obama on amnesty
It’s hard to believe, but Hillary Clinton is taking an even more extreme stance on immigration and executive actions than President Obama. At a campaign stop in Las Vegas, Clinton vowed she would fight for “full and equal citizenship” for the millions of illegal immigrants currently living in the U.S. “I will fight for comprehensive immigration […]
Huckabee claims he never criticized Beyonce

Mike Huckabee doesn't think calling Beyonce "vulgar" is criticizing her--it's just "making observations."

Former Clinton aide: Hillary likes wine, vodka

Two former Clinton aides spilled the secrets about Hillary's drinking habits and biggest regrets during a roundtable on HuffPost Live with Bloomberg's Josh Green and Politico's Glenn Thrush.

Scott Walker approves regulations for Uber, Lyft
Gov. Scott Walker signed a bill into law this month that regulates rideshare companies, including Uber and Lyft. The law stipulates certain safety features including the prohibition of hiring sex offenders, people with drunk driving offenses or habitual traffic violations. The company must also electronically transmit the driver’s photo and license plate number to the […]

Policy

Amnesty comes at a high cost in California
Amnesty comes at a high cost in California. California State Sen. Ricardo Lara (D-Bell Gardens) is hoping to grant health care coverage to illegal immigrants at the cost of $740 million per year, according to the Senate fiscal analysis. The bill, proposed last year by Lara, would extend government-subsidized healthcare coverage to 1.5 million people, according […]
Millennials least likely to support free speech
The results of a recent Pew Research Center poll on free speech should probably come as no surprise in this era of “trigger warnings” and “microaggressions.” But the poll found that Millennials were least likely to support free speech rights, particularly when that speech could be seen as offensive. The Pew Research Center polled a […]
Scott Walker approves regulations for Uber, Lyft
Gov. Scott Walker signed a bill into law this month that regulates rideshare companies, including Uber and Lyft. The law stipulates certain safety features including the prohibition of hiring sex offenders, people with drunk driving offenses or habitual traffic violations. The company must also electronically transmit the driver’s photo and license plate number to the […]
Emergency room visits have gone up under Obamacare
Another day, another lie stemming from the creators of the Affordable Care Act. Despite President Obama’s promises to the contrary, the number of visits to U.S. emergency rooms — one of the most costly parts of healthcare in America — has actually gone up under Obamacare. “Such irresponsible behavior costs all the rest of us […]
Anna Wintour comes out for Hillary & against guns
In an interview with New York Magazine, Vogue’s longtime editor and chief Anna Wintour, was asked about how “Hillary balked at the idea of being Vogue” during her 2008 presidential run. Despite being snubbed, Wintour announced she’s ready for Hillary. She said, “I hope so! Of course. Yes. But it’s only just started,” when asked if […]