Librarian of Congress criminalizes unlocked cell phones

Effective last week, the Librarian of Congress officially criminalized the unlocking of new cell phones, with fines for one-time offenders reaching as high as $500,000 in addition to up to five years in prison.

Unlocking cell phones so that they can be used on different carriers’ networks was a fairly common practice that presented a variety of potential benefits to consumers. As of January 31, a White House petition to rescind the decision has more than 46,000 signatures.

So how did an unelected bureaucrat (the nation’s top librarian) appointed to his position more than 25 years ago, end up with the power to criminalize what has until recently been a common activity?

Under the 1998 Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), which outlaws technologies that bypass copyright protections, the Librarian of Congress is directed to issue exemptions to law. The exemptions are only good for three years, and interestingly, the unlocking of new cell phones was previously exempted in both 2006 and 2010.

Although it’s one of the more absurd examples in recent memory, the Library of Congress isn’t the only federal agency issuing pseudo-legislation that affects millions of Americans without any input from their elected representatives in Congress.

In 2011, a controversial mandate by the Department of Health and Human Services required that private health insurance plans cover contraception, even for nonprofit groups that opposed contraception for religious reasons (you may recall that GOP support for a religious exception to the mandate was ridiculously labeled a “war on women”). Last year, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) issued new rules that effectively banned new coal-burning power plants.

Aside from being patently undemocratic, permitting librarians and other bureaucrats to exercise such wide-sweeping legislative authority also reduces transparency in government. This was supposed to be the “most transparent administration in history” after all.

Wireless carriers have been fighting for years to remove the DMCA exception for phone unlocking. How much influence might cellular companies like AT&T and Verizon have had in the chief librarian’s phone unlocking decision? It’s difficult to tell, but both companies are ranked as “heavy hitters” for lobbying and political contributions by the government transparency group opensecrets.org – AT&T was the tenth ranked lobbyist in the country in 2012.

Constituents also know how to lobby their elected officials and follow developments in Congress, but they are generally clueless about how to participate in complex agency rule-making processes. The Librarian of Congress formally announced his prohibition on phone unlocking back in October 2012, but most Americans didn’t even notice the rule-making until three-months after the decision was already made. Federal agencies are making enormously influential decisions on behalf of Americans and most people don’t even know it!

Government by librarian – it doesn’t get any more absurd than that.

Comments

Comments

  1. mark says:

    This is beyond absurd! Once again, why should anyone have faith in any large corporation? They continue to wrench every last penny out of us using nods and winks and although legal, is never in the best interest of the consumer. Government by librarian… Pathetic.

  2. dvid says:

    What kind I say. Oops to us for allowing people in government to make this decision. Let’s fire them all and start over.

Polititainment

GoT Author to host Democrat Fundraiser
The red fundraiser? In this case, the appropriate color is probably blue. George R.R. Martin, the author of the popular book series “A Song of Ice and Fire” and the inspiration for HBO’s “Game of Thrones,” will host a fundraiser for Sen. Tom Udall (D- N.M.) in early October. According to Udall’s campaign, the event will […]
Jay Carney's son performs at White House

The former White House press secretary and now CNN political commentator tweeted out a photo of his son's band Twenty20 performing at a White House event Monday evening.

Stewart: Graham has panicked for 13 yrs
Comedian Jon Stewart is taking some time away from going after his favorite Republican war hawk Sen. John McCain and is now going after McCain’s fellow rally crier, Sen. Lindsey Graham. Graham had some strong words over the weekend on the topic of ISIS, saying,  ”This president needs to rise to the occasion before we […]
Actress: I made 'constitutional' stand

Django Unchained actress Daniele Watts said Monday morning that she made a stand for her "constitutional rights" in resisting the LAPD late last week.

Gillibrand Madam Secretary inspiration

After first revealing that CBS' upcoming "Madam Secretary" series was inspired by Hillary Clinton and Benghazi, the show's producers are now saying that Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-N.Y.) was more of the inspiration for the lead role.

 

White House

Joe Biden should never be allowed to support a Redskins name change

Imagine for a moment a tied Senate vote urging the Washington Redskins to change their team name. Into the chamber steps Joe Biden.

Gaffetastic vice-president apologizes for slur

Vice-President Joe Biden apologized Wednesday for his use of an ethnic slur in a speech this week.

Two remarkable stories show why these Vietnam vets earned an exemption to receive the Medal of Honor

Two Vietnam War veterans who were granted an exemption to receive the Medal of Honor were officially recognized Monday, recalling the extraordinary courage of servicemen often obscured by the tumultuous domestic politics of the era.

Obama orders airstrikes in Syria for first time

WASHINGTON (AP) — Opening a new military front in the Middle East, President Barack Obama authorized U.S. airstrikes inside Syria for the first time Wednesday night, along with expanded strikes in Iraq as part of a broad mission to root out the violent Islamic State militants whose reign of terror has spread across both countries.

Golf courses are now rejecting President Obama

A president can no longer just golf like a major champion today.

Congress

Rand Paul: Millennials 'aren't as wedded to party'
Sen. Rand Paul (R – Ky.) seems to have the majority of millennials figured out. The presidential hopeful spoke with The Federalist this week about his foreign policy views and the shift toward libertarian views among millennials. “I think the libertarian influence, the libertarian-ish Republican, the libertarian conservatives in many ways is great for the […]
Democrats turn on Debbie Wasserman Schultz
POLITICO – Democratic National Committee Chairwoman Debbie Wasserman Schultz is in a behind-the-scenes struggle with the White House, congressional Democrats and Washington insiders who have lost confidence in her as both a unifying leader and reliable party spokesperson at a time when they need her most. Long-simmering doubts about her have reached a peak after two […]
'Finally, we're gonna audit the Fed'

The House passed a bill Wednesday afternoon to audit the Federal Reserve, a long-time crusade of former Rep. Ron Paul and libertarians.

No welfare for weed under House bill
WASHINGTON (AP) — The House passed a bill Tuesday night that could make it a little harder for people to use government welfare payments to buy marijuana in states where the drug is legal. Supporters call it the “no welfare for weed” bill. The bill would prevent people from using government-issued welfare debit cards to make purchases […]
Congress tweets the Constitution

For an alternative reading experience this Constitution Day, direct your attention to Darrell Issa's Twitter feed.