Philly ‘Romney-Ryan’ HS student to sue math teacher, district over incident

It looks like the district’s decision to install condom machines in high schools isn’t the only controversy surrounding the Philadelphia School District this week.

The parents of 16-year old Samantha Pawlucy, the Philadelphia high school student who was taunted by her geometry teacher for wearing a Romney-Ryan T-shirt to school, filed a lawsuit in federal court against the teacher and the school district over the incident late last week. The Pawlucys’ suit alleges that the district and teacher Lynette Gaymon violated their daughter’s right to free speech and subjected her “to emotional distress, simply because she exercised her First Amendment rights.”

The family is also seeking damages for emotional distress, claiming that Gaymon defamed Pawlucy by suggesting that she was a racist and for allowing other students who disagreed with her political views to harass her, and is seeking a judge to enjoin the district to ensure that this doesn’t happen to other students.

“This is Philadelphia, the birthplace of freedom and things like that, but we have schools that want to take away her freedom,” the girl’s father said.

When asked by the Philadelphia Inquirer last week Philadelphia School District spokesman Fernando Gallard refused to comment on the lawsuit. In October Gallard acknowledged that Pawlucy had not violated any school codes by wearing the T-shirt.

Pawlucy wore the shirt to Charles Carroll High School on a casual dress day this past September. According to Fox 29 Philadelphia, the girl’s math teacher – Gaymon – took offense to her shirt, telling her that she “can’t wear a Republican shirt in a Democratic school” and that wearing the shirt was akin to being a member of the Ku Klux Klan. Gaymon then enlisted an aide to draw on Pawlucy’s shirt with a red Sharpie after she refused to take it off and allowed Pawlucy’s fellow classmates to mock her for the shirt.

She received a hero’s welcome when she returned to school on October 10th, commenting that ”(I’ve learned) to stand up for myself. Don’t let people tell me that what I’m doing is wrong” upon her return.

While Gaymon has since apologized, Pawlucy’s parents continue to call for her resignation and have removed their daughter from that high school. Governor Romney also called Pawlucy in October to praise her courage in handling the situation.

On Election Day the school district also sparked some controversy when it was ordered by a judge to temporarily cover a mural of President Barack Obama on the wall of a high school gymnasium that was being used as a polling site.

 

Comments

Comments

  1. crazymensa says:

    As with the media, teachers and professors feel it is their civic duty to instill our children with their opinions on just about anything. I have had children in high school and college who have had to deal with this and were subjected to ridicule from the teacher(s) and other students. My daughter was bullied teachers (in HS) for standing up for her constitutional right of freedom of speech. Because she was constantly bullied by the teachers and students (nothing was done by the administrators) she decided to transfer to a cyberschool, where she graduated. These people are not paid to teach nor give their opinions, especially politically. If religion cannot be mentioned (let alone taught) then so should it be that political opinion and affiliation should not be tolerated. This is the type of rhetoric that breeds hatred and violence; maybe the fingerpointers ought to take a look to whom the three fingers are pointing back…

  2. Mike S says:

    Freedom of speech includes the freedom to respond to that speech or message. This is important to remember when we have to listen to someone spewing absolute crap. We do not have to sit back and be silent. I support this girl and am proud of her. The teacher and teachers aid should never step foot in a class room again. Their response attempted to silence the girl rated then simply respond. We must be careful not to silence responses or our responses will be silenced.

  3. t. says:

    I’d like to know just where on that tshirt did the “aid” use a SHARPIE?? This is bullying, plain and simple, AND a violation of free speech AND destruction of private property AND quite possibly something akin to assault, depending on how the “Sharpie action” was executed.

    The “teacher” (according to their website a student teacher?) should be disciplined. Without any disciplinary action the school has, in effect, supported the action and made it clear to students and faculty alike that similar future action will go unpunished.

    Because no disciplinary action has been taken to date, I think Samantha has a good case.

    Hope she gets a pile of money. Paying out always makes schools start paying attention.

Polititainment

Brazile says she brings 'realism' to TV
Democratic National Committee Vice Chairwoman Donna Brazile is a real life actor who brings “realism” to your living room and she wants you to know it. The New York Times published a letter by Brazile Wednesday that was apparently in response to a NYT critic who dinged Valerie Jarrett’s recent appearance on “The Good Wife.” The […]
Stewart: How a bill becomes an ad

Jon Stewart observed Tuesday night that, although Congress doesn’t pass many laws these days, all those bills don’t go to waste—instead they are reborn into campaign ads slamming opponents for not voting on something.

Stewart wants to move 'home' to England

Jon Stewart is having second thoughts about the whole “American independence from Britain” thing.

Colbert: Obama is stealing Bush's lines

Colbert observed Monday night that some of Obama's recent comments on ISIS and Iraq seem a little familiar.

Liberal lobbying firm makes ‘Bibi-Yoncé’

If you’ve ever thought that the complexities of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict reminded you a lot of a Beyoncé song, liberal Middle East lobbying group J Street has the internet campaign for you!

White House

Holder resigns with 26 percent approval rating, making him third least popular Obama cabinet member

Attorney General Eric Holder’s dismal 26 percent approval rating as he steps down from his duties still leaves him as only the third least popular Obama administration official to resign.

Barack Obama doesn’t celebrate National Coffee Day. He celebrates tee time.

Look. We get it. The president gave his coffee salute, The Semper Latte, just days ago, recent enough to use for National Coffee Day jokes from dusk 'til decaf. But aren't we missing an opportunity here?

U.S. Grants $450M to Community Colleges To Link Job Training To Employers
WASHINGTON (AP) — Vice President Joe Biden announced almost a half-billion dollars of grants Monday to community colleges working with employers on job training. Linking training to industry demand is key to the Obama administration’s strategy for improving wages and reducing unemployment. Massasoit Community College in Massachusetts and Wisconsin’s Chippewa Valley Technical College received the […]
WH: Secret Service’s ‘task is incredible’
THE HILL – The White House said Sunday it remained confident in the Secret Service despite news that the agency didn’t realize for five days that bullets had hit the White House in a 2011 shooting incident. “I know the Secret Service is on top of this and they will take every necessary step to correct […]
Even hardcore left states don’t believe Obama is doing a good job
President Obama is facing more bad approval ratings, but this time they are coming from states that used to be his biggest fans. Just 39 percent of registered voters in New York responded to a new Marist College poll that they believed Obama was doing an “excellent” or “good” job. This is the lowest level […]

Congress

Lawmakers react to Secret Service resignation

Secret Service Director Julia Pierson tendered her resignation Wednesday in the wake of news of multiple security breaches and testimony before Congress this week.

John Boehner: Obamacare 'has to go'

In an interview with USA TODAY Tuesday, House Speaker John Boehner affirmed that Obama's championed but disastrous Affordable Care Act "has to go."

McCain: Rand Paul 'trusts me' in military matters

McCain thinks he would wield a great deal of influence over a potential President Paul, “particularly on the military side of things.”

Rep introduces bill to ban porn on gov. computers
Most people wouldn’t think to browse porn at work, but then again, most people aren’t federal employees. Earlier this year it was discovered that one EPA official had been browsing pornography for two to six hours a day while at work and now Rep. Mark Meadows, (R-N.C.) has introduced a bill explicitly “prohibit[ing] the access […]
DWS repeated 'back of his hand' line
Apparently when Democratic National Committee Chairwoman Debbie Wasserman Schultz finds a phrase she likes she is going to repeat it, no matter how offensive. For the second time within the past month, footage of the DNC chairwoman has surfaced in which she accused a Republican governor of giving women “the back of his hand.” Republican Super […]