Britain’s failed tax-hike experiment should serve as a red flag for Congress

As the battle over tax rates for top-earners escalates on this side of the Atlantic, the American media has largely ignored Great Britain’s recent tax-increase debacle.  After sticking it to the rich by pushing top tax rates from 40 percent to 50 percent in 2010, Britain lost two-thirds of its millionaires and £7 billion in tax revenue.  In response, Britain is dropping the top rate down to 45 percent next April.

The embarrassing announcement complements a March report by Britain’s tax-collection agency detailing the apparent negative effects of the tax increase (the first increase of the top rate in the UK since 1988).  Concluding that there was “considerable behavioral response” to the tax increase, the report details how the tax hike stunted economic growth, caused substantial (legal) tax avoidance, and likely made the UK “a less attractive place to start, finance and grow a business.”

Wouldn’t the British government’s own admission that raising top-income tax rates actually reduced revenue and hurt economic growth be relevant to the current American tax debate?

One doesn’t even have to look across the Atlantic to see the negative economic effects of soaking the rich.  California, with one of the highest tax rates in the country, has been hemorrhaging its population to more tax and business-friendly states at an alarming rate.  The state’s comically high tax rates also didn’t prevent the unprecedented bankruptcy proceedings several large California cities earlier this year.

Nonetheless, President Obama and Congressional Democrats are willing to ignore economic reality in pursuit of “fairness” (which, unlike revenues and GDP, is an abstract concept and impossible to measure).

Obama summed up the left’s view perfectly during a 2008 debate performance.  When questioned by the moderator on the historical fact that recent reductions in the capital gains tax rate resulted in greater revenue, while the last increase in the rate resulted in reduced revenue, Obama insisted that the rates should be increased anyway “for the purposes of fairness.”  The “rich need to pay their fair share” meme continues to be a principal talking point on the left.

If your goal is to stoke class resentment among less-wealthy Americans for political gain, then the fairness argument is a winner.  But if your goal is to grow the economy and increase revenue, Great Britain’s failed tax-hike experiment should offer a grim warning to Democrats and a reason to maintain some political backbone among Republicans.

At the end of the day, fairness doesn’t reduce the deficit; revenues do.

Comments

Polititainment

Jay Carney's son performs at White House

The former White House press secretary and now CNN political commentator tweeted out a photo of his son's band Twenty20 performing at a White House event Monday evening.

Stewart: Graham has panicked for 13 yrs
Comedian Jon Stewart is taking some time away from going after his favorite Republican war hawk Sen. John McCain and is now going after McCain’s fellow rally crier, Sen. Lindsey Graham. Graham had some strong words over the weekend on the topic of ISIS, saying,  ”This president needs to rise to the occasion before we […]
Actress: I made 'constitutional' stand

Django Unchained actress Daniele Watts said Monday morning that she made a stand for her "constitutional rights" in resisting the LAPD late last week.

Gillibrand Madam Secretary inspiration

After first revealing that CBS' upcoming "Madam Secretary" series was inspired by Hillary Clinton and Benghazi, the show's producers are now saying that Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-N.Y.) was more of the inspiration for the lead role.

 

Maher compares GOP rep. to ISIS, Ebola

Liberal comedian Bill Maher announced who he calls the "winning loser" in Congress during a live taping of "Real Time with Bill Maher" in Washington, D.C., Friday, and that loser is Rep. John Kline (R-Minn.).

White House

Two remarkable stories show why these Vietnam vets earned an exemption to receive the Medal of Honor

Two Vietnam War veterans who were granted an exemption to receive the Medal of Honor were officially recognized Monday, recalling the extraordinary courage of servicemen often obscured by the tumultuous domestic politics of the era.

Obama orders airstrikes in Syria for first time

WASHINGTON (AP) — Opening a new military front in the Middle East, President Barack Obama authorized U.S. airstrikes inside Syria for the first time Wednesday night, along with expanded strikes in Iraq as part of a broad mission to root out the violent Islamic State militants whose reign of terror has spread across both countries.

Golf courses are now rejecting President Obama

A president can no longer just golf like a major champion today.

Crushing: The golf industry fights the Obama administration

How's this for a hook: The golf industry is fighting the Obama administration.

Little boy face plants on White House couch in front of President Obama

The above photo from the White House Flickr account shows a little blond boy more taken with the White House's comfy couches than with President Obama himself.

Congress

Senator tells ISIS war protestors to get lost

The anti-everything activist group Code Pink loudly crashed a Senate hearing on ISIS Tuesday, prompting the committee chairman to tell the rowdier members to get lost.

Pelosi not sure how she feels on money in politics
House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi appeared on “Late Night with Seth Meyers” Monday night to talk money in politics, but her tone on the subject changed significantly from beginning to end. Host Seth Meyers brought up Sen. Ted Cruz’s recent speech on the campaign finance amendment proposed by Democrats. Cruz opposed the amendment and warned […]
GOP has advantage in midterms on immigration

Politico poll conducted between August 29 and September 7 shows that voters deciding this tight races trust Republicans over Democrats to handle immigration.

Poll finds that likely voters remain uninformed
A Rasmussen poll released on Thursday found that just weeks before the midterm elections, more than one-third of Americans likely to vote in 2014 don’t know which party controls the House and Senate. For months political analysts have been anxiously trying to predict if the country’s dissatisfaction with President Obama’s policies will be enough to […]
WaPo analysis shows Democrats driving polarization
President Obama and many leading Democrats are publicly complaining that Republicans have created a polarized political environment which prevents them from accomplishing necessary business, like immigration reform and Obamacare. But according to the analysis of L.J. Zigerell, a political scientist writing for the Washington Post, the reverse is true. Over the past 30 years, Democrats […]