Cutting Waste and Fraud Is Not a Medicare Reform Proposal

A candidate who promises to preserve, protect, and defend Medicare, save it from going bankrupt, implement his plan for only those under 55, and let you keep your benefits exactly as they are now if you don’t like his changes: this is the candidate Democrats are portraying as a faceless monster diabolically wheeling grandma off a cliff.

We’ve reached the apotheosis of the Democratic Party’s political strategy: take the Republican who’s most likely to do it the favor of justifying, rescuing, and strengthening its bloated, big-government welfare programs, and then smear him as their callous, murderous destroyer.

Ten days after Mitt Romney’s Vice Presidential nomination announcement, liberals are still spreading the meme that Paul Ryan was a suicidal choice, because he dared come up with a serious Medicare reform proposal—gradually turn the program into a voucher-supported private system—and include it in two House-passed federal budgets.  The Left waited five minutes after the VP pick, then cried, “See! Romney didn’t get a Ryan bounce. He screwed up!”

Wait until Americans hear Ryan debate Joe Biden and field questions from a smarmy, economically illiterate, and biased press. Then they won’t be crowing that Romney committed hari-kari.

Pundits imply that Romney should have picked a VP candidate with no strong positions on Medicare or any other issue of substance, lest he alienate independents. But the opposite will hold true: if any voters truly are undecided, they’re going to be blown away by what Ryan has to say on Medicare and every other budgetary topic he addresses in his upcoming campaign appearances, because it’s so much bolder and more honest than what any other politician has said to date.

Since they don’t like the Big Bad Wolf’s proposal, what are Democrats’ plans for shoring up Medicare?

They have none. They don’t even think there is a problem.

The New Yorker’s John Cassidy argues that Medicare is doing just fine, and that the only reason costs are out of control is the large number of retiring Baby Boomers.

Contrary to Democrats’ claims, Medicare is not more cost-effective than private health insurance. The federal government prohibits the sale of private health insurance across state lines, which cripples the private insurance industry’s ability to compete and innovate.  No such hindrance exists for Medicare.

Medicare is not more cost-effective than HMOs. The IRS hamstrings HMOs by virtually forcing health insurance plans to be tied to employers rather than employees, which reduces flexibility and competitiveness. No such obstacle exists for Medicare.

Medicare could never survive on its own, not without sponging off of the much larger private insurance industry. If Medicare had such a bright future, more doctors wouldn’t be refusing to accept Medicare patients with every passing year.

So what is Obama’s proposal to address Medicare’s imminent bankruptcy? He says that we don’t need to cut benefits… that we can keep it solvent simply by reducing fraud and waste. In his words, “My plan saves money in Medicare by cracking down on fraud, and waste and insurance company subsidies… My plan’s already extended the life of Medicare by nearly a decade.”

Please. Every politician who wants to preserve the status quo and eschew cutting a dime from a popular federal program claims that gobs of money can be saved just by reducing fraud and waste. Everyone wants to reduce fraud and waste. John Gambino wants to reduce fraud and waste.

Obama also claims he can save hundreds of billions of dollars by reducing subsidies to insurance companies and hospitals—as if they’re going to altruistically pony up the difference rather than cutting services or finding a way to pass the cost on to customers.

Democrats show no interest in accepting that Medicare is going broke, and that benefits will soon be cut. They live in a fantasy land where, at best, they pretend they can save hundreds of billions of dollars via rosy projections of improved Medicare cost-efficiency a few years down the road, after the next couple of election cycles, by which time voters have forgotten about their unfulfillable promises.

At worst, they ignore the problem and demonize Republicans for proposing solutions.

Comments

Comments

  1. Rich K says:

    The key here is the last paragraph of Mr. Spiegel’s piece…”Democrats show no interest in accepting that Medicare is going broke, and that benefits will soon be cut.” If the President doesn’t think it is an issue, his lemmings will ignore the issue as well. So what you have here is an apathetic body of partisans who feel nothing is wrong. Fantasyland in real time….

  2. sda53 says:

    obama plans to kill off the old as fast as possible so naturally he has no plan for Medicare. I listened to Ryan today and like his plans. At least he has a plan, unlike obama who is so arrogant we are not allowed to question him. Medicare does need to be revamped and protected for people the age of my children. We put that money there and it was never to be in the general fund much less stolen from to start a new agenda. Without our permission that money should not be touched. This is just like if a bank took what you had out of savings and told you they would spend it wiser than we would. obama should be prosecuted for this alone not to mention the other hundred reasons. Unseal his records Congress and do your job to get rid of this traitor, muslium, foreigner you let in office.

Polititainment

Clooney: Release 'The Interview' online

George Clooney may have the most awesomely toothy response to the Sony Pictures cyberattack that forced the movie studio to pull the film "The Interview" from its December 25 release.

Jon Stewart might ruin your childhood

Jon Stewart brought his nightmare-inducing recurring character “Gitmo” on the show to talk about the normalization of U.S. relations with Cuba.

Colbert's embargo on the Vatican

Colbert had to chide his audience Wednesday night for getting excited about making “Cuba more libre.”

Megyn Kelly on 'The Interview'

Fox News’ Megyn Kelly told Jimmy Kimmel she found Sony’s decision to pull “The Interview” after threats of a terrorist attack "deeply troubling.”

Romney's suggestion for 'The Interview'

Mitt Romney has an idea to turn "The Interview" movie fiasco into a win for everybody.

White House

District court declares Obama’s executive action on immigration unconstitutional
A federal court in Pennsylvania declared parts of President Obama’s executive actions on immigration unconstitutional Tuesday. Judge Arthur J. Schwab, sitting in the western district of Pennsylvania, said presidents do have the power to use discretion in deciding how to enforce laws, but found that Obama’s recent executive action went much further than that.  He said Obama was writing […]
Obama administration extends Pell grants to juvenile offenders
The Obama administration has set out new guidelines that allow for students sentenced to juvenile correctional facilities to be eligible for federal Pell grants. The U.S. Department of Education and Department of Justice sent out a joint release Monday that clarified an earlier law. Congress in 1994 prohibited inmates at federal and state prisons from receiving Pell Grants […]
White House denies report that it wants to delay release of CIA torture report

The White House is insisting it wants the Senate Intelligence Committee to release its report on CIA torture practices, despite a report that Secretary of State John Kerry is trying to scuttle it.

Kate visits NYC kids; Prince William joins Obama

NEW YORK (AP) — Prince William's wife, Kate, wrapped Christmas gifts, helped preschoolers decorate picture frames and left an impression of a down-to-earth royal as she toured a child development center Monday with New York City's first lady.

The surprising opponents and backers of Obama’s net neutrality plan

Ted Cruz vs. Justice Scalia, and Obama vs. Jesse Jackson and the NAACP: The fight in Washington over "net neutrality” and has drawn up some strange battle lines.

Congress

Rand Paul: 'Opening up Cuba is a good idea'

Sen. Rand Paul broke with the Republican Party's prevailing argument against President Obama's Cuba policy Thursday, saying the move toward opening trade with the long-embargoed nation "probably" is a good idea.

Retiring DemHenry Waxman's farewell ode to govt

You'd think that, 40 years in, a congressman might grow cynical about the prospects of government meddling. Not retiring Rep. Henry Waxman (D-Calif.)!

Senate Confirms Pro-Gun Control Surgeon General
NATIONAL JOURNAL — The Senate narrowly confirmed a new surgeon general whose nomination was delayed for months in a fight over his comments alleging that guns are a public health issue. The confirmation represents a victory for gun-control advocates, even as recent polling has shown Americans moving in the other direction toward gun-rights protections. The […]
Congress gave DOD $3 billion in extra funds

Christmas came early for the Pentagon (and Lockheed Martin.)

Rand Paul's bill to repeal Obama's exec order

Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.) has filed a bill to overturn President Obama’s executive action on immigration.