MTV’s ‘Fantasy Election’ Based on Biased Scoring

A network that was instrumental in establishing connection between Obama and youth voters in 2008 has developed a new way to increase student interest in the coming election.

MTV has announced plans to release a new online competition related to the 2012 elections modeled after fantasy sporting leagues.

The game, Fantasy Election ’12, will allow friends to create teams of election candidates and compete against other fantasy teams to earn the most points.

What’s deceptive about this fantasy format is that candidates only receive points based on select criteria chosen by MTV, designed to measure each candidate’s political performance. Some of the criteria include:

-The use of the political fact-checker Politifact, whose “facts” have been found to be wildly inaccurate and usually directed to political figures on the Right.

-The amount of activity a candidate devotes to using the social media sites Facebook and Twitter as a means to connect with potential voters

-The civility of each candidate, based on the campaign ads aired by that candidate in different media markets, as measured by the Wesleyan Media Project.

-Whether or not a candidate is willing to take Project Vote Smart’s Political Courage Test, a questionnaire that measures the openness of candidates about their political stances on election issues.

-Willingness to disclose campaign funding, as recorded by the Center For Responsive Politics.

While MTV’s fantasy game is certainly a unique effort to increase student awareness in the upcoming election cycle, there are several issues with their chosen format that will bias the scoring of candidates.

For one, nearly all of these sources could be considered subjective in the material that they publish.

The ratings system employed by Politifact has an incredibly wide spectrum for interpretation, and also employs a certain degree of emotion in reporting the “truth” of a politician’s statement. When Politifact is checking the validity of certain statements by politicians, they assign ratings based on their “Truth-O-Meter”.

The system includes ratings such as “Mostly True”, “Mostly False” and “Pants on Fire,” which is reserved for statements deemed to be completely false, but are considered especially egregious in the eyes of their editors. MTV’s Fantasy Election ’12 will distribute points each time a candidate says something that is rated to be “True” by Politifact.

Monitoring the civility of each candidate is a concept that is laughable at best, as attack ads have been shown to be incredibly effective for influencing voters at the polls. Both Democrats and Republicans use attack ads, and polls have shown that 70 percent of the ads aired in the 2012 election cycle have been negative.

Finally, some of the point criteria are simply not relative to politicians from certain areas.

Candidates who come from states where fewer households have internet access may spend very little time on Twitter, compared to candidates who come from big cities.

There is also the issue that candidates who are more well known may be fact-checked a greater number of times compared to candidates who haven’t received as much media coverage. Statements made by House Speaker John Boehner (R-Ohio) will likely face a higher degree of scrutiny compared to statements by a backbencher like Rep. Aaron Schock (R-Ill.).

MTV’s latest voter awareness project lacks the broad range of sources to be established as truly non-partisan. With a points system that is clearly biased in terms of distribution, a confusing system political fact-checking and a focus on issues such as civility and campaign spending, Fantasy Election ’12 is merely a means to create issues that are ultimately irrelevant to the prosperity of our country.

 

Comments

Polititainment

'SNL' laughs at North Korea, Sony hacks
“Saturday Night Live” hit on North Korea and the Sony hacks twice this weekend, proving that unlike most of Hollywood, they aren’t scared of Kim Jong-un. The show started off with a bang, bringing back Mike Myers as Dr. Evil to interrupt the cold open and discuss his anger over the North Korea and Sony hacker […]
RNC asks theaters to show 'The Interview
The Sony hack and subsequent cancellation of “The Interview” has gone fully political. President Obama made an official statement on this decision and now the Republican National Committee is weighing in. RNC Chairman Reince Priebus asks that movie theaters not bow down to North Korea and stand up to this decision by screening the film […]
Obama: LeBron 'did the right thing'

President Obama supports LeBron James' decision to wear an "I can't breathe" t-shirt during warmup before the NBA game between the Cleveland Cavaliers and Brooklyn Nets last week.

Al Sharpton, Hollywood's Sony Liaison

In a private meeting with Rev. Al Sharpton at the Greenwich Hotel in New York City Thursday, Sony Pictures chair Amy Pascal told Sharpton that he could have a voice in how the movie studio makes its films.

Clooney: Release 'The Interview' online

George Clooney may have the most awesomely toothy response to the Sony Pictures cyberattack that forced the movie studio to pull the film "The Interview" from its December 25 release.

White House

Obama: I will do ‘everything I can’ to close Guantanamo Bay
President Obama may have signed the defense bill that keeps Guantanamo Bay open for another year, but he is still verbally promising to close down the facility. Obama appeared on CNN’s “State of the Union” Sunday and discussed closing Gitmo by the end of next year with host Candy Crowley. “I’m going to do everything […]
Obama: ‘We’re not going to be intimidated’ by Sony hackers
President Obama appeared on CNN’s “State of the Union” Sunday morning and covered a variety of topics ranging from racism to North Korea and the Sony hacks. Obama repeated his earlier statements about the hacks, implying again that Sony made the wrong call by canceling screenings of “The Interview.” “The Boston Marathon suffered an actual […]
Obama: we can’t have censorship subject to ‘some dictator someplace’

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Barack Obama declared Friday that Sony "made a mistake" in shelving a satirical film about a plot to assassinate North Korea's leader, and he pledged the U.S. would respond "in a place and manner and time that we choose" to the hacking attack on Sony that led to the withdrawal. The FBI blamed the hack on the communist government.

U.S. confirms North Korea was behind Sony attack and promises ‘proportional’ response

Officials no longer merely suspect North Korea to be behind the cyberattack on Sony Picture—they’ve confirmed it.

District court declares Obama’s executive action on immigration unconstitutional
A federal court in Pennsylvania declared parts of President Obama’s executive actions on immigration unconstitutional Tuesday. Judge Arthur J. Schwab, sitting in the western district of Pennsylvania, said presidents do have the power to use discretion in deciding how to enforce laws, but found that Obama’s recent executive action went much further than that.  He said Obama was writing […]

Congress

Rubio, Paul feud continued on ABC's 'This Week'
Likely 2016 presidential hopefuls Marco Rubio and Rand Paul have been going after each other all week for statements made on President Obama’s decision to normalize relations with Cuba and the feud did not take a break over the weekend. The Florida senator, one of the most outspoken critics of the new Cuba policy, appeared on […]
Rubio says Rand Paul is clueless on Cuba

Sen. Marco Rubio made his criticism of a fellow Republican plain Thursday night.

Gowdy's office responds to Speaker chatter

Rep. Trey Gowdy has become a sensation on the Right, with his no-nonsense style and committee hearing takedowns of Obama officials garnering him praise and attention.

Rand Paul: 'Opening up Cuba is a good idea'

Sen. Rand Paul broke with the Republican Party's prevailing argument against President Obama's Cuba policy Thursday, saying the move toward opening trade with the long-embargoed nation "probably" is a good idea.

Retiring DemHenry Waxman's farewell ode to govt

You'd think that, 40 years in, a congressman might grow cynical about the prospects of government meddling. Not retiring Rep. Henry Waxman (D-Calif.)!