Maddow Update Indirectly Acknowledges That Previous ‘Scoop’ Was Wrong

As we reported over the weekend, on her April 6 show Rachel Maddow claimed to have a breaking news report on a current legislative controversy in Michigan.

In the report Maddow falsely asserted Michigan Republicans were using an “unprecedented” power grab to pass an extensive number of bills with an immediate-effect clause without acknowledging that Michigan Democrats had previously used the same clause and voting procedures when they controlled the Michigan legislature by very similar margins.

On Maddow’s Monday program, she ran an update on the story in response to what she said was criticism from both sides of the isle and a decision by the Michigan Appeals Court to overrule a previous court order and side with Michigan Republicans. The Appeals Court ruled to allow several bills passed with the immediate-effect to become laws now.

In other words, the Appeals court saw nothing wrong with the process that was used to pass those specifics laws. Maddow did not outright acknowledge her factual inaccuracies or unfair contentions in the first report, but did finally concede that “both sides have done this.”

End of story, right? Nope. Not to be outdone, Maddow’s contention has now graduated from an unprecedented circumvention of democracy to the argument that Republicans should have requested a roll call vote in the Michigan House when the Democrats previously used the same exact procedure to pass laws with the immediate-effect clause.

So now, she is indirectly admitting that her big “scoop” is simply that Michigan House Republicans are using the same voting procedures that have been used for years.

She also used the segment, once again, to try to tie likely GOP presidential nominee Mitt Romney to the “controversy” surrounding Michigan Republicans’ actions via his father George Romney, the former Governor of Michigan. George Romney presided over the convention where the state approved a constitutional amendment requiring 90 days to pass before a law could be enacted after it was passed by the state legislature unless an immediate-effect clause was attached.

The segment on Monday ended with Maddow saying that her program will continue to cover the story in Michigan.

“On a personal note, I have to say I am more inclined than ever to stay on this story,” she said. “One, because it keeps getting more and more interesting and more and more fraught all the time. I think something is going on Michigan that’s not going on anywhere else in the country, and it deserves a lot more attention than it’s getting.”

She also claimed she would not be discouraged from covering the story even as her “detractors” insulted her.

“But also, turns out your insults make me stronger Bring it on, keep shooting the messenger.”

The problem with that assertion is that her detractors are not actually insulting her or “shooting the messenger,” rather they are pointing out that she was pushing a dishonest, partisan message.

Let us hope her continued coverage will include more fact-based reporting and less false contentions focused on attacking Republicans.

 

Comments

Comments

  1. William says:

    But, the republicans don’t have a two-thirds majority to pass these bills with immediate effect.

Polititainment

Actress: I made 'constitutional' stand

Django Unchained actress Daniele Watts said Monday morning that she made a stand for her "constitutional rights" in resisting the LAPD late last week.

Gillibrand Madam Secretary inspiration

After first revealing that CBS' upcoming "Madam Secretary" series was inspired by Hillary Clinton and Benghazi, the show's producers are now saying that Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-N.Y.) was more of the inspiration for the lead role.

 

Maher compares GOP rep. to ISIS, Ebola

Liberal comedian Bill Maher announced who he calls the "winning loser" in Congress during a live taping of "Real Time with Bill Maher" in Washington, D.C., Friday, and that loser is Rep. John Kline (R-Minn.).

Paul Ryan not keen on Rage

Everyone’s favorite iron-pumping, fiscal-hawking, ice bucket-lifting, Rand-reading, chart-drawing 2016 presidential possibility is Raging no longer.

Sharknado 3 could be heading to D.C.
Because apparently two “Sharknado” movies weren’t enough, the SyFy Channel has already confirmed a third film in the series. The official location has been kept hush-hush, new reports indicate that Washington D.C. may be the latest city to be devoured by flying sharks. Showbiz 411 reports: “‘Sharknado 3,’ the next installment of the now classic […]

White House

Two remarkable stories show why these Vietnam vets earned an exemption to receive the Medal of Honor

Two Vietnam War veterans who were granted an exemption to receive the Medal of Honor were officially recognized Monday, recalling the extraordinary courage of servicemen often obscured by the tumultuous domestic politics of the era.

Obama orders airstrikes in Syria for first time

WASHINGTON (AP) — Opening a new military front in the Middle East, President Barack Obama authorized U.S. airstrikes inside Syria for the first time Wednesday night, along with expanded strikes in Iraq as part of a broad mission to root out the violent Islamic State militants whose reign of terror has spread across both countries.

Golf courses are now rejecting President Obama

A president can no longer just golf like a major champion today.

Crushing: The golf industry fights the Obama administration

How's this for a hook: The golf industry is fighting the Obama administration.

Little boy face plants on White House couch in front of President Obama

The above photo from the White House Flickr account shows a little blond boy more taken with the White House's comfy couches than with President Obama himself.

Congress

GOP has advantage in midterms on immigration

Politico poll conducted between August 29 and September 7 shows that voters deciding this tight races trust Republicans over Democrats to handle immigration.

Poll finds that likely voters remain uninformed
A Rasmussen poll released on Thursday found that just weeks before the midterm elections, more than one-third of Americans likely to vote in 2014 don’t know which party controls the House and Senate. For months political analysts have been anxiously trying to predict if the country’s dissatisfaction with President Obama’s policies will be enough to […]
WaPo analysis shows Democrats driving polarization
President Obama and many leading Democrats are publicly complaining that Republicans have created a polarized political environment which prevents them from accomplishing necessary business, like immigration reform and Obamacare. But according to the analysis of L.J. Zigerell, a political scientist writing for the Washington Post, the reverse is true. Over the past 30 years, Democrats […]
Clyburn: 'Sexting' can encourage people to vote
Freudian slip or simple mistake? Rep. James Clyburn (D- S.C.) encouraged the use of “sexting” on C-SPAN recently, calling it a great “tool” to get people out to vote. As first noted by the Daily Caller, Clyburn was responding to a caller who was concerned about the Michael Brown and Trayvon Martin shootings. He told […]
Dems attempt to amend the Bill of Rights fails
Senate Republicans unanimously rejected a proposed constitutional amendment Thursday afternoon that would have restricted political speech. The amendment was designed by Democrats as a way to allow Congress would authorize Congress and the states to regulate and limit fundraising and spending on federal candidates. It would also prevent the Supreme Court from reversing any future campaign finance […]