Biased Study Claims People are Conservative Because They’re Uninformed

As it does annually, Gallup recently conducted a poll asking Americans to identify their ideology. For the third year in a row, the results showed that nearly twice as many Americans identify themselves as “conservative” as opposed to “liberal.”

Liberal scholars have often tried to explain these results away by attacking the simplicity of conservative beliefs.  The latest incarnation of this attack is that conservatism tends to be the natural position of someone who has not had “the time or energy to give a matter sufficient thought.”

This suggestion is based on a study from University of Arkansas psychologist Scott Eidelman.  The study essentially tested the way that the ideologies of individuals were influenced by constraints such as time, alcohol impairment and distraction. The researcher’s main conclusion appears to be “that when effortful thought is disengaged, the first step people take tends to be in a conservative direction.”

The suggested implication of this conclusion is that much of conservatism’s support is based on individuals not really thinking things through.

Quite a few things are wrong with this explanation.  First, the study does not really address the political ideologies of Americans. The Gallup survey was not conducted under similar constraints. Individuals who participate in that survey have had their whole lives to determine what ideology suits them, including many moments where “effortful thought”  was required, and they were not disengaged. In addition to some serious concerns about methodology of the survey (the study was based on extremely low sample sizes and limited locations), this conclusion doesn’t necessarily fit the research.

The researchers seem to ignore other possible and more likely explanations for the results. That’s where the study becomes less about science and more about explaining away a fact that the researchers find inconvenient.

There is no actual evidence within the research that there is a lack of meaningful thought leading constrained individuals to lean toward more conservative positions. In fact, an explanation that is equally probable is that much of conservative ideology is based in common sense; therefore it takes much less effort for someone to arrive at that position.

Liberalism is rooted in the idea that others can make better decisions for an individual than they can make for themselves, and it often depends on deceptive rhetorical framing, extensive obfuscation of issues and selective facts to enforce that belief.

Therefore it would be a perfectly justifiable and at least equally fitting conclusion that when individuals are constrained – and therefore not influenced by the various outside framings on particular issues – they would revert to their natural position of applied common sense. This is just one possible conclusion that could have fit the research just as easily.

The study provides no definitive answers as to why so many Americans more identify themselves with a conservative ideology as opposed to a liberal one or why that is a more instinctive position for many.  One thing that does seem to be certain is the researchers should be giving more “sufficient thought” to how their biases are constraining them from making proper conclusions.

Comments

Comments

  1. scott says:

    do your homework and actually read the article.

    1. the authors never made any connection between gallup polls and their research (you’re getting confused with a journalist’s speculation).

    2. the methodology was completely sound, and more than adequate for basic hypothesis testing.

    3. there *is* direct evidence for the role of effortful thought in producing the results – all studies, especially study 4 (where mediation is used)

    4. common sense is completely consistent with the authors explanation, and not an “alternative” one.same goes for the

    6. the author of this post should give more sufficient thought to what he claims to be knowledgeable of, and actually read the article before taking other people’s misinformed conclusions as those of the researchers.

Polititainment

Ted Cruz loves 'The Simpsons'

Ted Cruz really likes "The Simpsons." The Republican presidential candidate detailed his fandom during an interview on The Federalist Radio Hour Thursday, spotlighting two of his favorite episodes of the cartoon television series.

Rubio asked to 'spit rap lyrics'

Marco Rubio, friend of Pitbull, fan of explicit 90s rap lyrics and Nick Minaj, and 2016 presidential candidate, has sadly declined an offer to perform his lyric-spitting talents on live TV.

Gwyneth Paltrow quits food stamps

According to the New York Post's Page Six, the actress has already dumped the food stamps challenge she agreed to last week, binging on two gourmet dinners in one night.

Maher: Obama should be a better bragger

The host of HBO's "Real Time" labeled the $1 million he donated to a pro-Obama Super PAC in 2012 -- an amount he won't ever give in support of Hillary Clinton -- a "great investment," commending the president on his accomplishments.

Tiny child weeps over Hillary 2016

When Hillary Clinton announced her presidential campaign yesterday, you were probably devastated. So was tiny Zeke here.

t u

2016

Perry knocks 'young' GOP foes ahead of 2016

The possible 2016 contender during remarks to reporters in Nashua, New Hampshire, Thursday compared declared GOP presidential candidates Ted Cruz, Rand Paul and Marco Rubio to President Obama in order to illuminate why the young senators aren't yet the right leaders for the White House.

Jeb Bush: 'I don't need to go to Chipotle'

While munching and mingling with fellow Republicans at the Snow Shoe Club in Concord, New Hampshire, Bush was asked whether he frequents the fast-food chain Chipotle, at which Hillary Clinton was photographed purchasing lunch earlier this week in Maumee, Ohio.

Cruz, Rubio, Santorum on attending a gay wedding

Which 2016 candidates--declared or otherwise--would attend the gay marriage of a loved one?

Hillary's 'Scooby' van is handicapped

No, Hillary Clinton is not handicapped at the ripe age of 67. However, that didn't stop the Democratic candidate for president from apparently sticking her "Scooby" van in a handicap parking spot while stopping at a cafe in Council Bluffs, Iowa, Thursday.

Hillary Clinton attacks CEO pay

The now-official Democratic candidate sent an e-mail to supporters following her campaign announcement that lamented the fact that regular Americans currently face economic difficulties "when the average CEO makes about 300 times what the average worker makes"

Policy

The TSA trained Disney World, SeaWorld

Disneyland, where dreams come true and TSA-trained employees are watching your every yawn and fidget and marking you down as a possible terrorist.

Marijuana: Not just for stoners any more

The media always loves to accompany stories about marijuana policy with bad puns and pictures of stoners.

Cruz, Rubio, Santorum on attending a gay wedding

Which 2016 candidates--declared or otherwise--would attend the gay marriage of a loved one?

Poll: Millennials financially optimistic

Crippling college debt aside, young people are feeling pretty good about their prospects of late.

Grassley: VA wrongly putting vets on gun ban list

Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) is demanding the Justice Department account for the fact that a “disproportionate” share of those on a “mental defective” gun ban list are veterans.