What to Watch For When Supreme Court Hears Obamacare Arguments

On March 26th, the Supreme Court will begin hearing three days of oral arguments on the constitutionality of Obamacare.  Some legal experts are calling the decision the Roe v. Wade of our generation, and that’s probably not an exaggeration.

The primary question before the Court is whether the commerce clause in Article I of the Constitution authorizes Congress to mandate that individuals purchase health insurance.  This boils down to how the court defines “economic activity.”

The Justices must decide whether an individual’s decision to forgo health insurance becomes economic activity by virtue of the fact that at some point in their lives they must participate in the healthcare market.  The slippery slope potential of that reasoning should be obvious: just about anything Americans choose to purchase or not purchase has some broader economic consequence.

Former Bush Solicitor General Paul Clement, advocate for the 26-state coalition challenging the law, can be expected to focus extensively on this lack of a “limiting principal.”  If Congress can regulate Americans who intentionally chose not to engage in commerce, then Congress’ power is essentially without limit.  Thus, the Court’s ultimate opinion has the potential to either make or break the idea that the Constitution restricts Congress’ authority to limited enumerated powers.

The big question for legal observers is whether Chief Justice John Roberts, Justice Anton Scalia, Justice Samuel Alito and Justice Anthony Kennedy will reveal their leanings during the arguments.  Count on the questions and demeanor of these Justices to be closely scrutinized for any hints as to their ultimate decision.

The Obama administration only needs to convince one of the four Justices mentioned above to win the case, as the four liberal Justices are almost certain to uphold the law.

Despite the usual critique of Justices as strict political partisans, there’s no guarantee that all of the “conservatives” on the Court will strike down Obamacare’s individual mandate.

Both Roberts and Scalia have written prior opinions that hint that they could be convinced of the mandate’s constitutionality.  In fact, The Hill reported last week that the Department of Justice is shifting its legal arguments in the case to arguments that Justice Scalia has previously endorsed.  Roberts is also on record supporting the view that Congress has some powers that are not specifically delegated by the Constitution.

Alito’s views on the relevant issues in the case are anyone’s guess.

Justice Kennedy, the Court’s usual swing vote, is probably the most likely to side with the liberal wing.  Constitutional scholar Erwin Chemerinsky joked to The Washington Post that he would “put Justice Kennedy’s photo on the cover” of the Court briefs if the rules allowed it.

If the court overturns the individual mandate, it would be a major repudiation of the liberal theory of governance which assumes that Congress should be given virtually unlimited discretion in addressing economic problems.  On the other hand, if the individual mandate is upheld, the Court’s conservative revolution is more or less dead.  The stakes couldn’t be higher.

Comments

Comments

  1. [...] of the unpopular law. Democrats are eager to shift the public’s opinion of the law before the Supreme Court hears testimony next week on the constitutionality of the law, which Republicans argue (and at least one Congressional Democrat admits) went outside the [...]

  2. Dboy says:

    Sarah Palin caused all that? This from a woman that the lfitest news media and politicians have repeatedly declared inept? Think what she could have done if she were ept . I believe the reason that people fear a possible death panel is the government’s habit of letting programs morph into something other than their original intent.SSI was intended to be insurance for the truly poor so that they would have at least something in their old age. Now it’s a retirement program for everyone.Medicare was to be safety net for the truly indigent, now it’s an entitlement program that includes capable people that can’t be bothered with using their tattoo and piercing money for their babies food.Obamacare is full of vague regulations that can be just as easily modified.

Polititainment

Madeleine Albright T(witter)KOs Conan

Former Secretary of State Madeleine Albright bested Conan O'Brien by Twitter knockout Thursday night, ribbing the comedian with a comeback worthy of a seasoned pro.

Kimmel: Stoner idea or gov. expenditure?
Sen. Tom Coburn’s (R – Okla.) fifth annual “Wastebook” was released Wednesday and some of the federally funded projects are so outrageous that they can be hard to believe. Late night host Jimmy Kimmel had the same thought and offered his audience a quiz. He read the name of a project, some real and some […]
Obama channels Chris Rock again

At rallies for Democrats in Maryland and Illinois on Sunday, Obama dropped the name "Cousin Pookie" -- a character that he used frequently to energize black voters during his 2008 campaign -- during his speeches.

Oliver beats Supreme Court's camera ban
Comedian John Oliver is sick of the Supreme Court ban on cameras in the court room and the ridiculous ways it makes television news stations have to cover those cases. But all hope is not lost. “What happens at the Supreme Court is way too important not to pay attention to and yet the ban […]
Stewart and Colbert go after 'Fangate'

Both Jon Stewart and Stephen Colbert had a field day with “Fangate” Thursday night.

White House

Obama is withholding over 15,000 Fast and Furious documents

President Obama claimed executive privilege to withhold over 15,000 documents relating to Operation Fast and Furious, including nearly 20 emails sent between Attorney General Eric Holder and his wife.

White House fence jumper charged with assault
WASHINGTON (AP) — The 23-year-old Maryland man who climbed over the White House fence Wednesday night has been charged with felonies for assaulting two police dogs and making threats, the Secret Service said Thursday. Dominic Adesanya of Bel Air, Maryland, is in custody of the U.S. Marshals Service for previous outstanding warrants, Secret Service spokesman Brian Leary said. […]
President Obama, unpaid bills and the curious editing of the White House transcript
President Obama, some unpaid bills and a curiously “inaudible” section of the White House recording of a speech — that’s how all good stories start, right? While at a Democratic National Committee fundraiser in Chicago, Obama cracked a joke about the “unpaid bills” at his home. The joke was reported by the White House Press […]
Secrecy shrouds how the Obamas cook their chicken wings

Now it seems the Obamas are tight-lipped even about their eating habits.

Obama delivers devastating blow to red state Democrats, calls them ‘all folks who vote with me’
President Obama can’t seem to stay out of the 2014 midterm elections, no matter how much his fellow Democrats want him to. Obama spoke on Al Sharpton’s radio show Monday, which was later replayed on MSNBC, insisting that red state Democrats are still his “strong allies.” “A lot of the states that are contested this time […]

Congress

Rand Paul: ‘The war on terror is not over’

Rand Paul attempted to lay out his recently evolving foreign policy vision at his speech Thursday night at the Center for the National Interest.

McCarthy speaks out against 'Truthy' study
Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy is joining the growing dissent against the federally-funded “Truthy” study designed to monitor political speech on social media. In a blog post Thursday, titled “#KillingFreeSpeech,” McCarthy promises that the House Committee on Science will be conducting oversight “in the coming months on this and other questionable government-funded research projects.” “Why does the government […]
CIA agents impersonated Senate staffers to snoop
Despite a number of growing foreign and domestic threats over the summer, the CIA admitted that they had been using their resources to spy on elected officials in the Senate. Now, insiders are alleging that it’s not just what they did that is the problem, but how they went about it. A new piece by the […]
Republicans say they will reform the IRS

Republicans are talking about reforming the IRS if they gain the majority in the Senate next month, but seem to be treading with caution on making any specific promises.

'Wastebook' finds $25B in 'unnecessary' spending
Monkey gambling, synchronized swimming sea monkeys, and mountain lions on treadmills, oh my! Sen. Tom Coburn (R – Okla.) released his fifth and final “Wastebook” Wednesday, chronicling $25 billion tax dollars spent on 100  “silly, unnecessary, and low priority projects” this year. His findings are absolutely astonishing. Coburn, who is retiring this year, is not letting his fellow […]